08 May 2020

Certain groups of migrants have been hit particularly hard by the coronavirus, and people have started to question why. Anna Bredström, who conducts research into ethnicity, has examined health equality. “Today, health is not equal. It has become obvious for many that this group is extremely vulnerable. It’s positive that the issue is receiving attention, but it must be done in a manner that doesn’t exacerbate the problem”, she says.

Portrait of Anna Bredström who is conducting research the role of etnicity and migration in health and health care.
Anna Bredström.

Doctors raised an alarm in March: Somalis in Sweden are heavily over-represented among those who die from COVID-19. Other ethnic groups, such as African Americans in some US states, have subsequently also been recognised as over-represented. And the question immediately arose why this is the case.

The availability of information in various languages was considered to be one cause, and Swedish official agencies introduced information campaigns. Other social and cultural factors have also been brought up in the public debate: cramped housing, difficulties in working from home, and a tradition in certain cultures to remain close to sick relatives and friends to care for them.

“It’s my perception that the official agencies have focussed on classic social causes such as cramped housing and the fact that many have a type of work that does not allow them to work from home. These aspects are extremely important”, says Anna Bredström.

A public debate focussed on culture

She is, however, at the same time sceptical that the focus is often placed on culture. Anna Bredström’s research concerns how ethnicity and migration shape health, healthcare and the production of biomedical knowledge. She considers that the over-representation of certain groups raises a larger question about health equality.

She points out that she has not systematically studied the particular debate about the corona crisis and migration, but she does recognise the arguments from other contexts in which questions of migrant health are discussed.

“Culture and cultural differences are often brought up as an important aspect, and it may be this idea that I am most sceptical about. It’s not the case that culture is not important. Culture plays a role in how we experience and interpret symptoms. It also affects the way in which we seek medical care”, says Anna Bredström.

But she believes that we must consider the concept of culture in the right way. It is easy to simplify this, and create stereotypes instead of understanding. This contributes to a form of cultural racism in which the cultures of certain groups are seen as problematic.

Anna Bredström points out that what is seldom discussed in the public debate is how ethnic discrimination influences the healthcare system. She has previously studied how different groups are met by such bodies as local healthcare centres, youth clinics, and maternity care.

“Health and healthcare are, unfortunately, not equal. Some groups hesitate in seeking care as a result of previous experience of negative encounters. Further, the way in which the healthcare system is organised makes it rather inaccessible for many groups.”

Ethnicity and genetic differences

Another topic that the media has mentioned, although not to any great extent, is whether genetic factors play a role in vulnerability to the coronavirus. This is a further aspect in which Anna Bredström is interested, and her research will follow this during the pandemic. Together with her colleague Shai Mulinari at Lund University, she is studying how ethnicity is used in population genetics.

“The aim of the genetic research is to bring more accurate diagnoses and develop tailored treatments. We are studying genetics from the perspective of the social sciences, and investigating the consequences of an interest in genetic variation within and between different groups. Will studies in genetics lead us to consider ethnicity as a biological property, and if so, what effect will this have on questions of racism and equal health?”

An interest in genetic variation has led to an increased focus on both race and ethnicity in medical research, principally in the US.

“A critical debate is under way about the with danger of focussing on ethnicity and race,” says Anna Bredström, “but this debate also deals with questions relating to justice and such questions as which groups are represented in clinical trials of various drugs.”

“It will be interesting to see the extent to which this is picked up in research into the novel coronavirus, and what effects it will have. Will genetic differences be studied as a possible cause for the over-representation of certain ethnic groups in the statistics? And if so, will the explanation based on genetic differences win territory from other explanations such as social background and culture?”

Can the pandemic stimulate measures to increase health equality?

The public debate has discussed the fact that certain ethnic groups have been hit hard by the coronavirus, and the question has arisen why this is the case. Anna Bredström believes that this is a step in the right direction. But much depends on the measures that politicians choose to adopt.

“Of course, there’s a risk that the image presented by the media will reinforce stereotypes and racism, but even so I believe that it’s positive that the differences in vulnerability are highlighted. It has generated some initiatives that may lead to improvements. But if the changes are to be permanent, we must understand what has to be done and we have to take it seriously. Otherwise, there’s big a risk that after a year or so we will just continue as usual. The issue of equality is truly a question for our politicians.”

Translated by George Farrants.

Contact

More LiU research on COVID-19 and its effects

Eleonore von Castelmur in the lab.

Coronavirus spurred research across disciplines

As the corona pandemic swept across the world, virologists and protein chemists rapidly joined forces and started to collaborate. Together they were able to develop ways to test the immune response after infection, and help the healthcare system.

Fredrik Gustafsson and Toomas Timpka looks into the camera.

Researchers critical to flawed Covid-19-models

Reports from Imperial College regarding the spread and the effects of Covid-19 had considerable policy impacts in several European countries. But the models that informed the reports have considerable flaws, according to LiU-researchers.

A close up on a womans eye with a contactlens in the forefront.

New contact lens might be used for treatment of covid-19

Mehrdad Rafat, senior lecturer at the Department of Biomedical Engineering (IMT), is hoping that their bioengineered lens can join the forces against the corona virus.

Latest news from LiU

Keti Chukhrov.

“The Swedish academic world is very unique”

Keti Chukhrov has appreciated her year at LiU as the Tage Danielson visiting professor. She is impressed by the democratic organisation and the true spirit of assistance and collaboration at IKOS, LiU.

The supercomputer Berzelius.

Supercomputer Berzelius to be upgraded to double capacity

The supercomputer Berzelius is used for research in fields such as life sciences, machine learning and artificial intelligence. This autumn, it will be upgraded thanks to a donation of SEK 125 million from the Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation.

New and old oil filter.

Making remanufacturing profitable

Returning end-of-life products to as-new condition is called remanufacturing. For more industrial companies to take an interest in it, remanufacturing needs to be economically viable. Johan Vogt Duberg has investigated how this can be accomplished.