25 November 2024

We distance ourselves from completely neutral products if they are liked by people who have political views that we find disagreeable. This is shown in four studies from Linköping University. The behaviour is reinforced if we have to make a decision when others are watching.

Woman eating av piece of chocolate.
 Chocolate that is liked by political opponents becomes less appealing. Photographer: Makidotvn

Political distancing affects us more deeply than was previously known and governs our choices even when it is completely irrelevant. The studies show that even chocolate can be political.

“From a social perspective, it can unfortunately be rational to distance ourselves from these neutral things, but this contributes to a more polarised society,” says Arvid Erlandsson, senior associate professor at the Department of Behavioural Sciences and Learning at Linköping University.

In four studies, researchers investigated people’s attitudes to completely non-political products before and after these were linked to people or groups with different political views. As far as is known, this is the first time such an investigation has been conducted. The results have been presented in the journal Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin.

Clothes and politics

The first study concerned clothing. The more than 600 participants were first shown a number of pictures of people wearing formal clothes. The heads of the people were hidden. Participants were asked to give their opinion on the design, fit and colour of the clothes and how much they would want to buy them. They were also asked their views on political parties. They then had to re-evaluate the clothes, but this time the faces of the people wearing them were visible. It turned out that the faces belonged to well-known Swedish politicians.

Knowing about it might make you think twice.

This clearly affected the results in the second round. Clothes worn by a politician from the participants’ least liked party were now more often perceived as less stylish than in the first assessment.

Chocolate and politics

In the next study, more than 800 participants first gave scores to eight well-known chocolate brands and stated their political stance. They were then divided into groups for a second round. One group was told that a previous pilot study showed that their political opponents liked a particular chocolate the best. A second group was instead told which kind their own side preferred. They then made a new assessment.

It turned out that chocolate that was liked by political opponents had now become significantly less appealing. However, varieties that were liked by their own side did not become more popular.

“It’s less about you associating with what your own side likes and more about avoiding what’s liked by the opposing side,” summarises Arvid Erlandsson.

Portrait of Arvid Erlandsson outdoors.
Senior Associate Professor Arvid Erlandsson.Photographer: Jonas Roslund

Charities and politics

A third study similarly examined willingness to donate money to various charities. More than 1,200 people participated and the results were the same as in the previous studies. Participants were less likely to give money to organisations they were told were preferred by political opponents.

The researchers think that we unconsciously behave this way to maintain a consistent self-image. What the participants did not know was that the pilot study showed that everyone – regardless of their political affiliation – had actually liked the same chocolate varieties and the same charities.

The importance of appearences

In the last study, 1,295 people participated. They also had to choose between products, but with a difference. One group made their choices while being observed by animated faces they were told belonged to their own political grouping. It turned out that the tendency to distance oneself from products liked by political opponents was further reinforced. The researchers’ conclusion is that we attach great importance to how we appear to others.

“Knowing about it might make you think twice, instead of just going on a gut feeling,” says Arvid Erlandsson.

The research was funded by the Swedish Research Council.

Translation: Simon Phillips

Article: Politically contaminated clothes, chocolates, and charities: Distancing from neutral products liked by outgroup or ingroup partisans, A Erlandsson, A Nilsson, J Rosander, R Persson, L Van Boven , Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, online 20 november 2024, doi.org/10.1177/0146167224129839

Contact

Four persons in chairs on a stage.

AI can boost financial decision making

Do you have limited financial knowledge, or prefer not to think about financial issues? Then there is great potential that AI can help, according to LiU researcher Kinga Barrafrem.

Nathalie Hallin and Hajdi Moche in conversation.

Religious people are not more generous – with one exception

Believers are no more generous than atheists – at least as long as they don’t know what the recipient believes in. This is the conclusion of a study carried out at LiU

A women is doing computed tomography.

JEDI-lab

We at JEDI lab at Linköping University conduct research on intuition, reflection, and emotion in economic decision-making. The aim of our research is to understand everyday decision-making and its underlying processes.

Organisation

Latest news from LiU

Server room and data on black background.

Machine Psychology – a bridge to general AI

AI that is as intelligent as humans may become possible thanks to psychological learning models, combined with certain types of AI. This is the conclusion of Robert Johansson, who in his dissertation has developed the concept of Machine Psychology.

Research for a sustainable future awarded almost SEK 20 million grant

An unexpected collaboration between materials science and behavioural science. The development of better and more useful services to tackle climate change. Two projects at LiU are to receive support from the Marianne and Marcus Wallenberg Foundation.

Innovative idea for more effective cancer treatments rewarded

Lisa Menacher has been awarded the 2024 Christer Gilén Scholarship in statistics and machine learning for her master’s thesis. She utilised machine learning in an effort to make the selection of cancer treatments more effective.